Learn › Games & Activities › The Impossible Choice
Debate & Persuasion
🪙 The Impossible Choice
Choose between two imperfect options and explain which tradeoff you can live with.
What you need
Pairs of imperfect choices.
How to play
- Read two options.
- Choose one—you may not invent a third option.
- Explain the biggest benefit of your choice.
- Admit its biggest downside and explain why you still choose it.
See one in action
Choice: pause time for 10 minutes every day OR rewind one mistake every week.
Choice: rewind one mistake.
Benefit: one serious mistake could be corrected completely.
Downside: I lose the everyday usefulness of pausing time.
Why I still choose it: fixing one high-impact mistake each week matters more to me than gaining a few extra minutes each day.
The key is to admit the tradeoff instead of pretending your option has no weakness.
Choice: rewind one mistake.
Benefit: one serious mistake could be corrected completely.
Downside: I lose the everyday usefulness of pausing time.
Why I still choose it: fixing one high-impact mistake each week matters more to me than gaining a few extra minutes each day.
The key is to admit the tradeoff instead of pretending your option has no weakness.
10 ideas to try
Choose any one of these prompts and use the activity steps above:
- Pause time for 10 minutes every day OR rewind one mistake every week.
- Every school gets free lunch OR one extra hour of free time each day.
- Understand every human language OR communicate with every animal.
- Free public transportation OR twice as many public parks.
- Never wait in a line again OR never get stuck in traffic again.
- Always know when someone is lying OR always know when someone needs help.
- Have perfect memory OR learn any new skill twice as fast.
- Live in a tiny home five minutes from work OR a huge home 90 minutes away.
- Give up social media for a year OR streaming video for a year.
- Work four long days a week OR five short days.
Make it harder / funnier
After choosing, switch sides and defend the option you rejected. You may not say your original choice was better.
Why it helps
Builds comparison, tradeoff analysis, impact weighing, fair concession, and the ability to defend more than one perspective.
Ready to use this skill?
Try it in Debate Practice →Take the activity into a full SpeakCoachLab practice session.